What Would Change Your Mind?
For a long time now, my favourite device for clarifying disagreement or uncertainty has been to ask my interlocutor: “What would change your mind?”1 This humble question is a dialectical knot-loosener, a tool of analysis, a generator of psychological insights, a circuit-breaker for doomed discussions, and, when I turn it on myself, an effective way of helping me figure out when I’m being lazy or full of shit.
Often asking “What would change your mind?” helps my interlocutor and me to locate the critical premises that are keeping us apart. Occasionally, the answer is: “I would need to believe X”, but, as it happens, we both already share this belief—and in this way the apparent disagreement between us is reduced. Once in a while I text my son while the Q is going over the Manhattan Bridge and we discover that we’re actually on the same train, or even in the same subway car. We look up and find one another, much closer than expected.
Usually, though, my interlocutor and I do indeed disagree about X, but it is a more tractable thing to argue about. The effect of the question in the typical case is to clarify the structure of our respective positions.
I consider “What would change your mind?” to be a respectful question, even when asked with a touch of exasperation, and this can also smooth the way forward. The question says, in effect: “Well then, teach me how to convince you, honoured interlocutor, and I will try to tailor an argument that exactly meets your concerns.”
Another way I can signal respect when I ask this question is to indicate that I’m open to answering it myself. Sometimes I say something like “So, what would change your mind about this? For example, I think I might be more tempted to come around to your view if I believed X or Y, which I don’t.” This models good behaviour, and shows that the question is not just a cudgel to beat someone up with.
One thing that sometimes emerges with greater clarity with this approach is that my interlocutor would need to modify a significant number of other beliefs in order to change their mind about the topic under discussion. Beliefs live and move in coordinated networks, and so asking my question helps surface key aspects of the network more efficiently than many other dialectical approaches. In my experience, the question often draws people up short and there is a shocked pause in the conversation, as if they had suddenly caught sight of their own reflection where they hadn’t expected to. This is useful information for both sides. It can be a surprise to people to realize how dug into a position they are, or how central it is to their world view or identity.
And to be clear, there’s nothing necessarily wrong with that! For me to accept that the earth is flat, for example, I would need to revise an enormous number of my other beliefs: On top of the scientific issues, I would probably also need to believe that most of the world’s scientists and educated people are engaged in a sort of giant Truman Show-style conspiracy against me. It would be a huge project (for all practical purposes, impossible psychologically, so long as my Truman Show is running smoothly) for me to revise so many beliefs in the network of beliefs that make up my view of the world.
But of course, changing your mind is about more than the logical structure of a set of beliefs. One common obstacle to changing your mind is that you haven’t imagined—not even while defending the position—what it would be like to do it. Asking “What would change your mind?” can help people begin this imaginative process, and this is part of the psychological value of the question.
Or it can bring home that someone just won’t, or can’t, even imagine changing their mind. And so the question is also valuable as a circuit-breaker. Listen well, disputers of the internet: Many debates are both optional and pointless. If you are in an optional debate, the fastest way to identify it as pointless is to receive an entirely non-responsive answer to the question. You can walk away, and with a pretty good explanation in hand too.
Indeed, this is such a useful question that I try to turn it around on myself all the time. When I do, it can have the same startling, clarifying effect that it has on others, for all the reasons I just gave.
Perhaps more accurately: “What is the smallest change in your beliefs that would bring you around on this particular issue?”, but I have never needed to explain this, since everyone intuitively understands it. (And yes, there may be several good candidates for smallest.)↩︎